
Aliz Hotel Times Square
Best for being in the heart of Midtown nightlife, Broadway access, and a skyline rooftop experience.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Aliz Hotel Times Square is a 4-star, 287-room boutique in Midtown near Times Square with a rooftop bar and an on-site fitness center — good for theatergoers and travelers who want lively, central access. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is a 5-star, historic Upper East Side luxury property known for longstanding celebrity and cultural associations — best for travelers who want classic, high‑end New York service and proximity to Central Park and museums.
Updated · about 2.9 km apart

Best for being in the heart of Midtown nightlife, Broadway access, and a skyline rooftop experience.

Best for a classic, upscale Upper East Side stay near Central Park and museum row.
Aliz Hotel Times Square wins if you want a newer, more casual Midtown base close to Broadway, Times Square, and a high-rise rooftop bar — good for show nights and visitors who value central sightseeing and a lively after-dark scene.
The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel wins if you want traditional, full-service luxury on the Upper East Side with a full-service spa, a long reputation for high standards, and easy walking access to Central Park and major museums.
Bottom line: Pick Aliz for a contemporary, convenient Midtown experience and rooftop cocktails; pick The Carlyle for a refined, classic luxury stay and quieter access to the cultural institutions of the Upper East Side.
| Category | Aliz Hotel Times Square | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary boutique, energetic Midtown | Historic, refined Upper East Side luxury |
| Location | 310 W. 40th Street — steps from Times Square and Broadway theaters | 35 E 76th St — short walk to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art |
| Size | 39 stories, 287 rooms, no suites | 188 guestrooms (suites available) |
| Age / style | Opened 2018, modern build and design | Historic, Art Deco/classic hotel building |
| Pools | No pool on site | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | FARMTOBURGER (American) + Dear Irving on Hudson rooftop bar | Two restaurants and Bemelman's Bar; 24-hour room service available |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa; on-site fitness center with Peloton bikes | Full-service spa and health club listed |
| Known for | Rooftop skyline views and easy Broadway access | Longstanding celebrity associations and Rosewood luxury service |
| Family policy | Welcomes families; check-in must be by a guest 21+ | Not adults-only; welcomes a general guest mix (adults and families) |
Aliz sits on West 40th Street a short walk from Times Square and the Broadway theater district.
Choose Aliz for immediate Midtown access and easy theater nights.
The Carlyle is on East 76th Street, within a short walk of Central Park and major museums.
Choose The Carlyle for a quieter, museum-and-park–focused Upper East Side location.
Aliz offers 287 modern guest rooms across 39 floors; rooms are intended as single-room guest accommodations rather than suites.
Aliz is for travelers who want modern, straightforward guest rooms close to Midtown attractions.
The Carlyle provides a range of luxury guestrooms and numerous suite options in a historic setting.
The Carlyle is for travelers wanting classic, multi-room suite options and higher-end in-room amenities.
Aliz centers food and drink around FARMTOBURGER and the two-story rooftop Dear Irving on Hudson.
Aliz is aimed at guests who want casual American dining and a prominent rooftop cocktail experience.
The Carlyle offers multiple dining venues including Bemelman's Bar and two restaurants, plus 24-hour room service.
The Carlyle suits guests who expect formal dining options, classic hotel lounges, and around‑the‑clock room service.
Aliz’s standout features are its Dear Irving on Hudson rooftop and an on-site fitness center with Peloton bikes.
Aliz’s rooftop and fitness offerings make it a social, activity-oriented Midtown choice.
The Carlyle’s signature is its full-service luxury program: a full-service spa, limo/town car services, and high-end concierge.
The Carlyle is built around traditional luxury services and on-site pampering.
Aliz offers a free fitness center plus a rooftop bar that stays open late for cocktails and skyline views.
Aliz is better for active guests and those wanting a late-night rooftop scene.
The Carlyle provides a full-service spa and a quieter, more formal evening scene with iconic hotel bars.
The Carlyle fits travelers who want spa services and low-key, upscale evenings.

Aliz Hotel Times Square — steps from Broadway theaters and Times Square, with easy transit links.

The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel — historic luxury rooms and many suite options plus full-service spa.

Aliz Hotel Times Square — Dear Irving on Hudson spans the 40th–41st floors for panoramic city views.

The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel — a short walk to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Aliz Hotel Times Square — it’s within a 5–10 minute walk to Broadway theaters.
The Carlyle lists a full-service spa; Aliz does not have an on-site spa or a pool.
No. Both properties welcome guests of all ages; Aliz requires the guest checking in to be at least 21.
The Carlyle — located in a residential Upper East Side neighborhood near Central Park, it tends to be quieter than Midtown.
Explore how Aliz Hotel Times Square stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·